A new innovation came into being for the 1876 final. The teams would only change ends at half time as opposed to every time a goal was scored which had been the case up until this year. It proved a popular idea and has remained ever since.
Both the finalists had played in the final before but Old Etonians had yet to win the cup. Wanderers were bidding for a record third victory and so this scenario ensured that history would be made whatever the result.
Wanderers included just one survivor from their previous cup winning side of 1873, Team captain Charles Wollaston who had a winners medal from 1872 as well. The side also contained two players who had lined up in the 1873 final against the Wanderers for Oxford University. Both of them, Fred Chappell-Maddison and Francis Birley had gone on to win a cup winners medal the following year for the University and were now appearing in their third final.
The Old Etonians had the greater experience with five former cup finalists in their ranks. Arthur Bonsor and Albert Thompson were appearing in their fourth final having won winners medals in 1872 and 73 with the Wanderers. William Kenyon-Slaney, team captain Arthur Kinnaird and semi final winning scorer Julian Sturgis had been team mates of Bonsor and Thompson in the 73 final. Only Sturgis had not played in the previous years beaten Etonian side and these five set a record for the most number of players in one cup final team to line up against their former club. There was also the unique situation of brothers lining up for each side. The Lyttletons, Arthur and Edward for Old Etonians and the Herons, Hubert and Fred for Wanderers
A 3,500 crowd assembled for the final at the Oval but a few concerns may have been felt by the F A when they read that their cup final attendance was dwarfed by the 10,000 who turned up to watch the Scottish equivalant the same day.
The match was a tight affair, as cup finals usually are and it took thirty-five minutes for Wanderers to make the breakthrough with a goal from Edwards. Wanderers held their lead at the interval but Alex Bonsor, Etonian's scorer last year slammed home the equaliser five minutes into the second half. Extra time failed to settle the issue for the second year in a row and a replay was set for the following Saturday.
Despite the replay being arranged for a Saturday the attendance was a dissappointing 1,500 while yet again the attendance North of the border for the Scottish replay was three times that number. Like last year The Etonians again had problems getting a side together and while Wanderers remained unchanged, their opponents brought in Stronge, Faner and Lubbock for Thompson, Meysey and Welldon. Stronge and Lubbock had both been in
the Etonians beaten side last year and the latter was yet another player who had previously won the cup as a Wanderer.
The changes unsettled Old Etonians though and Wanderers made light work of winning the replay. Wollaston led with a Captains example by opening the scoring before Hughes took over to become the first player to score a brace in a cup final. The final scoreline of 3-0 was in no way flattering to the victors who had now set a record of winning the cup for a third time. Etonians meanwhile had still not been able to get their name on the trophy.