The third decade kicked off with the make up of the cup looking very different to ten years previously. The fancied teams now hailed from the North and the Midlands as opposed to the Southern sides of 1880. These teams were also paid professionals playing in sides formed by work's social clubs and church groups and carried the hopes of entire towns with them. Ten years before, the teams had been stoutly amateur and for the most part hailed from the officer’s mess or the old boy network and held no geographical fan base. Finally the biggest difference in ten years was that the cup was no longer the only show in town and ties had to be fitted in to suit the league programme.
The importance of league status was recognised for the first time by the F A who exempted its members from the qualifying competition. The rival football alliance that was set up for teams bypassed by the league looked on enviously as its member clubs were not afforded the same pleasure. They could hardly be surprised though as no alliance club got further than the quarter finals last year while the last four were all football league teams.
Cup holders Preston were red hot favourites to retain their trophy as they were already well on their way to retaining the league title. Newton Heath, later to become Manchester United could do little to halt the holders in round one. Geordie Drummond’s four goals helping Preston to an easy 6-1 win. The day of the giant killer had dawned though as Burnley fell at Sheffield United but they were the only league side to be humbled in such fashion.
Sheffield United’s joy was short lived as they slumped to a 13-0 defeat to Bolton in round two. Bolton had already notched up a 10-1 win over Belfast, now Lisburn, Distillery in the previous round. The cup holders faced Bolton at this stage after another comfortable 4-0 second round win over Lincoln but the unthinkable happened when the invincibles were humbled 3-2. With Preston’s defeat the cup was wide open and included two non-league sides in the other three quarter finals. Sheffield Wednesday had won the inaugural football alliance in 1889 and were considered the best non-league side in the Country. After beating Southern amateurs Swifts 4-1 in the first round, they then showed they were a match for the league teams by beating Accrington 2-1. Tom Cawley had scored in both games but few expected his team to beat a Notts County side with May and John Oswald up front. County had beaten Birmingham St George's 6-2 in a first round replay but were stunned to lose to Wednesday 5-0. County protested however and the F A ordered a replay that County won 3-2 only for Wednesday to lodge a protest of their own. At the third attempt Wednesday came through 2-1 with Cawley scoring both goals. Bootle were not so lucky in their quarter final with Blackburn Rovers. The Merseysiders from the football alliance had lost in the first round to Sunderland Albion but had been reinstated after the victors were disqualified. Nat Walton bagged a hat-trick for Rovers in an easy 7-0 win however. The last quarter final also had controversy when league sides Wolves and Stoke met with the former winning 4-0. Stoke protested about the pitch and were given a replay only for Wolves to double the previous score with Jack Brodie scoring five.
Wolves were last year’s beaten finalists but their dreams of a return to the Oval were shattered by a Jack Southworth goal for Blackburn in the semi final at the Racecourse in Derby.
Bolton were favourites to win the cup when they were paired with Sheffield Wednesday and were clearly on a high after knocking our Preston. The big danger in their team was Weir but Wednesday policed him well and pulled off a shock 2-1 win at Perry Barr in Birmingham with two goals from Albert Mumford.