For the third consecutive year the Football Association chose a new venue for the cup final. Fortunately this time their choice was a sensible one when they selected the natural bowl situated at the lare Victorian pleasure park at the Crystal Palace grounds in Sydenham in London. The Crystal Palace itself had been moed here after the great exhibition and the huge glass building dominated the area, also noted for it's famous switchback roller coaster ride. Spectators would once again be able to enjoy a day trip to London and be able to take in all the attractions the grounds had to offer before the game itself. The only down side to this venue was that the natural banks which surrounded the pitch offered very poor views of the action for those not lucky enough to be at the front while some fans would find their position was quite some way from the pitch itself. Despite this, the final of 1895 would prove to be a huge success and led the F A to make the Palace the home of the cup final for the next twenty years.
The competition itself was not one for great shocks this year as all eight quarter finalists hailed from the top flight, the first time since the league was formed that this had happened. Sheffield Wednesday were among them for the eighth consecutie time but had still not managed to get their hands on the cup. Wednesday put paid to the cup holders Notts County 5-1 in the first round before non league Middlesbrough suffered at the hands of Davis, whoe scored a hat-trick, and Fred Spikesley, with two in a 6-1 win. Wednesday hung on to home advantage again in the quarter finals with a much tougher test against title chasing Everton.
Everton's rivals for the championship were Sunderland and they too were chasing a league and cup double which began with five goals from Miller and a hat-trick from Hannah in an 11-1 romp against non league Fairfield in round one before Preston were knocked out in round two. Bolton would be making the trip to Newcastle Road in the quarter finals in their bid to bounce back from last years defeat. So far they had quietly progressed with a couple of 1-0 wins over Arsenal and Bury.
League Champions Aston Villa were also in this strong looking last eight having started their cup run with a 2-1 over Derby in one of the few all first division ties. Next up they had met the only giant killers of round one, Newcastle. The Geordies had stunned Burnley with a 2-1 win but the second division side came unstuck at Villa Park when the Champions ran out easy 7-1 winners to book a home quarter final against Nottingham Forest.
The last eight was completed by another Midlands club, West Bromwich Albion who got this far the hard way, coming through an away tie at Small Heath and then earning a replay at Sheffield United before winning at Stoney Lane. Local rivals Wolverhampton Wanderers lay in wait in the quarter finals.
All four ties were settled atthe first time of asking on March 2nd with Aston Villa making the headlines. Bob Chatt and Steve Smith helped themselves to a brace each in an easy 6-2 victory over Nottingham Forest at Villa Park. Sunderland's bid for the league and cup double remained on course at Newcastle Road where they eased past last years beaten finalists Bolton 2-1. Title rivals Everton saw their cup dream die at Owlerton as Sheffield Wednesday won 2-0. The tightest tie was the local derby between Albion and Wolves at Stoney Lane where Roddy McLeod's goal settled the tie in the home sides favour.
Sunderland were now installed as favourites for the cup but the dream final against Aston Villa was dashed when the two clubs were paired in the semis. Sunderland would go on to take Villa's crown as League Champions and their fans felt they had never had a better chance of laying their semi final hoodoo, they had lost all three of their previous semi finals including a 4-1 mauling by Villa in 1892. Things didn't change when the sides met at Ewood Park in Blackburn on March 16th. The clubs had battled out a 4-4 draw in the league two months earlier so goals were expected while Sunderland had a massive incentive that if the league and cup double was performed they would each earn an extra £20. Steve Smith was the hero for Villa though with both goals in a 2-1 win, Hannah scored Sunderland's consolation.
At Derby cricket ground West Bromwich Albion made a little piece of history as they booked their place in the final at luckless Sheffield Wednesday's expense. Hutchinson had already put Albion in front when they were awarded the first ever semi final penalty. Williams took the responsibility and calmly slotted home the second and killer goal for a 2-0 victory to set up a Midlands final.