Neither the fans of Derby or Forest had been afforded the chance to see their respective clubs play in a cup final before this meeting in 1898 so it was fitting that the weather helped to make the occasion a memorable one. The two sets of fans began to congregate in London from early morning on April 16th under cloudless skies and glorious sunshine. Sadly by the time most of the 62,017 fans arrived at Crystal Palace, the clouds had rolled in, though thankfully the rain stayed away.
Derby were considered overwhelming favourites to lift the trophy. They had the Nation's most famous and feared striker in their ranks in the shape of Steve Bloomer and it was hard to believe that he had yet to win a major honour in the colours of the Rams. Forest also were bidding to win their first major domestic trophy. In appreciation of his long service to the club, William Wragg was made captain for the day, John McPherson stepping down from that position for the match.
It was the tradition back in the Crystal Palace era for a photographer to take the two sides outside the stadium prior to kick off to be photographed both with and without the cup to avoid a photo of the winners with muddy shirts. As usual the photographer took his two snaps of the Derby eleven which would be syndicated to the pictorial press but when the forest team posed, the photographer was quite put out. He demanded they remove their scarlet red shirts and wear something else, his reason being that the shirts would show up as too dark in the dull skies behind. The bemused Forest players were ordered to swap shirts with their Derby opponents for the official photos. And so for a couple of minutes the entire Nottingham Forest team got the chance to see if they would suit being Derby County players before handing the shirts back to their opponents to get on with the more important issue of actually winning the cup.
As is always the case with the cup final, it took a while for both sides to find their feet. As usual it required a goal to spark life into the game and fortunately it came in the first quarter of the match. William Wragg's 19th minute free kick fell to Arthur Capes whose shot gave Jack Fryer in the Derby goal little hope of stopping. The underdogs were in front but their goal seemed to simply wake up what had been a lacklustre Derby side. Suddenly the Rams were playing at a much higher pace and there was a huge expectation of it being just a metter of time before the equaliser came. As it was, it had looked as if Forest had weathered the worst that Derby could throw at them when another free kick led to another goal. This time it was Forest's Frank Foreman who gave away the free kick which was whipped in for Steve Bloomer to score the goal he had surely been destined to. The Forest fans present would have been forgiven for thinking that their chance may have gone with that equaliser as the underdog who gets their nose in front is usually beaten when pegged back. On this occasion though, Derby recoiled back into their shell and allowed Forest to dictate the remaining fifteen minutes of the first half. The goal which spelled the end for Derby came just three minutes before the interval. It most certainly would not have been considered among the greatest cup final goals of all time either and it was a moment that haunted Jack Fryer for the rest of his days. A simple and tame shot came at Fryer at chest height for a simple catch but Fryer fumbled it and palmed the ball straight to Arthur Capes who had the simplist of tasks to put Forest 2-1 up. It was a crucial goal at a crucial time in the game as Derby found themselves having to lift their play again in the second half. Despite their more skillful side though, the Rams seemed unable to raise their game a second time and although they did put Forest on the back foot more and more as the second half progressed, Bloomer and Goodall and co consistantly failed to truely test Dennis Allsop in the Forest goal. The killer punch came four minutes from time. With Derby by then committed to all out attack they left themselves hopelessley vulnerable in defence giving John Mcpherson a deserved reward for having given up the captaincy to Wragg.
At the final whistle few of the Derby players were keen to talk but John Goodall summed up the mood by simply telling the press that "The better team on the day won and good luck to them."
Derby fans could have few complaints with Goodall's summing up, Forest had played like a side with nothing to lose and everything to gain to bring the cup to the red half of Nottingham for the first time, even if modern fans are sometimes misled to believe that Forest wore white that day.