If the idea of a Southern finalist had appealed to the London crowd in 1900 then the appearance of London's own Tottenham Hotspur in the final caused pandemonium. The last London team to play in the final had been Clapham Rovers twenty years before. The prospect of a huge crowd at Sydenham was heightened by the glorious spring weather in cup final week and on the day itself the sun shone from dawn. As is the custom, Sheffield arrived in London on the Friday night and checked into a nearby hotel but Tottenham did not see the need to do the same and their cup final side gathered at the clubs home ground before travelling together to the Palace. United came out on to the pitch first with nine of their eleven that had won the cup two years earlier and as a result they were overwhelming favourites. Tottenham followed with no cup final experience but they were making history as John Cameron became the first cup final player manager.
The game kicked off at 3.30 in front of the guests of honour, Lord and Lady Butler. With the wind at their backs, United started the game the better of the two sides and it wasn't long before Walter Bennett found himself with a golden chance to open the score only to fluff his lines. To Bennett's relief Fred Priest was not going to be as wasteful when he intercepted Harry Erentz's poor headed clearance in the tenth minute and fired in a daisey cutter to beat George Clawley and open the scoring. The fear among many Spurs fans was that they might fold in the same way Southampton had last year and it seemed to be the case as United turned the screw in search of a killer second goal. United paid for their failure to put Tottenham out of reach when Erentz's free kick was headed home by Sandy Brown in the twenty-third minute. Win or lose, Brown had made history as the first player to score in every round of the competition and he wasn't satisfied to rest at that. Within a minute of equalising, Brown rattled the United bar with a long range shot. There was no doubt that United were the side more grateful to hear the half time whistle.
Spurs started the second half as they had finished the first and it was a crucial period of the game for United who needed to hang on and wear Spurs down. United managed it for just six minutes as The entire Spurs forward line combined to rip open the United defence before Brown yet again fired the ball onto the bar. This time the ball carried on into the goal to give Spurs the lead but within a minute the game was level again but in very controversial circumstances. United kicked off in the fifty-second minute and straight away they were putting Spurs under pressure when a Fred Priest shot was charged down. Boots flew in everywhere in a goalmouth scramble before George Clawley finally got his hands on the ball to take the sting out of a mishit punt from Walter Bennett. Bennett tried to charge the keeper but Clawley simply side stepped him and punted the ball upfield only for the referee, Arthur Kingscott to signal for a goal. Everyone in the ground was shocked at the decision although the United players were not going to complain. To the credit of the Tottenham players they didn't surround Kingscott hurling oaths and pointing fingers in the way that
players today do. It was however the first case of trial by film footage as the Pathe cameraman caught the incident on film and it was clear that Kingscott's belief that Clawley had carried the ball over the line to avoid Bennet was a bad call. Sadly today the film of the incident has been lost but Kingscott's decision had denied Spurs the cup they deserved. The fans didn't need to see the film, they knew Spurs were robbed already and hooted and booed every time United crossed the half way line. Had a third goal been scored goodness knows what would have happened but thankfully the match ended 2-2 and a replay at Goodison Park in Liverpool was arranged for the following Saturday. In a new twist to the tail, Liverpool complained to the F A because they were playing a vital league game at home to Nottingham Forest less than a mile away at Anfield and that the cup final replay would affect their gate. So while Everton hastily arranged a friendly with Third Lanark to fill the now vacant fixture date in their programme, which for the record still attracted a higher gate than Liverpool, The cup bandwagon moved to Bolton's Burnden Park.
The move was a disaster as just 20,470 turned up for the replay, one of them being the guest of honour, nine times cup finalist, Lord Kinnaird. The knocks that both sides had collected the previous Saturday had cleared up and the same twenty-two players took the field for the match which was kicked off by Tottenham side who had made no secret of their disgust at the draw seven days earlier. Tottenham's sense of injustice went against them initially as it was United who took the lead five minutes before the break through Fred Priest. This replay was all about the second half display of Tottenham however. John Cameron provided a captains example to level the game in the fifty-second minute. If anything, United were the better side after that but yet again they didn't take advantage when on top and Smith gave Spurs the lead in the seventy-sixth minute. It was a killer blow to United who seemed to sense the fates were against them. Tottenham dominated the closing stages and it was no surprise when Sandy Brown chipped in with the third goal three minutes from time.
The cup had gone out of the football league for the first time since the league was formed and it is likely that it will never happen again. In a footnote, Tottenham fans have always been very proud of the idea that they were the first to tie riboons to the cup. Well they were the first to be presented with the trophy with ribbons attached but seven years earlier Notts County were photographed with ribbons on the cup. The tradition did not catch on until the Wembley era however.
TEAMS
TOTTENHAM HOSTPUR
GEORGE CLAWLEY
HARRY ERENTZ
SANDY TAIT
TOM MORRIS
TED HUGHES
JACK JONES {CAPTAIN}
TOM SMITH
JOHN CAMERON {PLAYER-MANAGER}
SANDY BROWN
DAVID COPELAND
JOHN KIRWAN
SHEFFIELD UNITED
BILLY FOULKE
HENRY THICKETT
PETER BOYLE
HAROLD JOHNSON
THOMAS MORREN
ERNEST NEEDHAM {CAPTAIN}
WALTER BENNETT
FIELD
GEORGE HEDLEY
FRED PRIEST
LIPSHAM
BOTH SIDES WERE UNCHANGED IN THE REPLAY.