The cup final rarely lives up to it's billing but it is hard to think of a final that was quite as poor as this clash in 1903. On paper it didn't look any more or less attractive than any other final between two mid table top flight clubs. In fact both Bury and Derby had made themselves fashionable cup fighters in the early Edwardian era and Bury in particular had come in for great praise for their semi final defeat of Aston Villa. Bury had finished the season slightly stronger than Derby and this was one of the reasons that they were regarded as slight favourites on the day. Five of their winning side from three years earlier, George Ross, Charlie Sager, William Wood, Joe Leeming and W Richards were back in search of a second winners medal but there was heart break for goalkeeper Montgomery who had deputised so well in goal in the semi final for Hugh Monteith. Derby also had five who had played in one or both of their previous finals. Jack Fryer and Jimmy Methven had played in both 1898 & 1899 while Archie Goodall and John May had played in the first and John Boag the second. The game certainly wasn't won and lost when Jack Fryer hid his pain when convincing the trainer that his groin injury had cleared up but Fryer's decision not to let the fit reserve keeper take his place certainly assisted in Bury racking up a record score.
It is sad considering how they have fared in the Century since to note that Bury were probably the poorest supported cup finalists of the twentieth Century. Only a few thousand bothered to make the journey to London and the local press didn't deem the cup final worthy of its front page. Fortunately Londoners and Derby fans were more interested and swelled the crowd to over 60,000 on a glorious spring afternoon in April.
The match they witnessed turned out to be one of the poorest in the history of the final. Bury played reasonably well and got into their game early on but Derby looked jittery and nervous and it was only the wayward finishing of Bury's strikers that didn't break the early deadlock or expose Jack Fryer's injury.
It couldn't continue like that and after twenty minutes, William Wood's cross eluded Joe Leeming and reached George Ross who caught the ball on a reasonable if not spectacular half volley from long range. A fit Fryer would have gathered the ball with ease but the handicapped keeper could only make a token attempt to stop Bury taking the lead. Needless to say Fryer failed to stop the shot and Bury had scored in front of a very muted crowd. That was pretty much all there was to report in the first half and there was plenty of opportunity for Derby to put right their awful first half display at half time.
The tougher talking at half time actually came from the Bury team who were annoyed that they had not killed Derby off, so dominant had their display been in the first half hour. There was a fear that Derby had got more into the game as half time approached and Bury were running the risk of following other previous losing finalists who had been the better side in the first half.
It didn't take Bury long to finish Derby off when the second half began. Within seconds of the restart Joe Sagar was unlucky to see his shot come back off the bar but he was luckier in the 48th minute when he beat Jack Fryer to Thorpe's through ball and slid it into the net for the second goal. This time Fryer couldn't hide his pain and Charlie Morris had to step in as a reluctant substitute goalkeeper. It proved a real baptism of fire for Morris who managed to keep Bury out for eight minutes before the inevitable third goal came on 56 minutes. William Wood crossed into the Derby box and Morris did well to get a fist to it. Sadly he didn't have the power of an experienced keeper and the ball fell to Joe Leeming who fired past the stand in keeper who was helpless to stop him. At 3-0 there was no chance at all of a Derby fight back so Jack Fryer decided to step back into goal for the remaining thirty-four minutes. He was picking the ball out of the net for Bury's fourth goal within a minute though. Again it was Charlie Sagar doing the damage as he let fly from the edge of the box, Fryer saved but couldn't hold it and William Wood gleefully slid the ball home. Now it was just a matter of how many goals Bury would score. Their few fans didn't have long to wait for number five, which came in the 59th minute. Derby were by now virtually down to nine men as Charlie Morris was crippled with cramp and when he was unable to clear the ball from the edge of his own area, Joe Leeming picked it up and set up John Plant for the fifth. By now the game was a virtual farce and there was still half an hour to go. Jack Fryer called it a day at this stage and left the field when Charlie Morris eased his cramp by taking over in goal. By now many of the Derby fans had seen enough and decided to take in some of the other entertainments that were available at the Crystal Palace grounds and many of the local neutrals had decided enough was enough as well. The final thirty minutes were played out to a half empty stadium that only served to help the final become a poor one. With fifteen minutes remaining Bury hammered one final nail into Derby's coffin whenJoe Leeming beat the offside trap to shoot past Charlie Morris for another soft goal. At 6-0 it may have been kinder for the referee to put Derby out of their misery. In one last tactical decision, Jimmy Methven took over in goal for the last ten minutes and at least he was able to boast a clean sheet. To be fair though nobody who was there can remember either side having a shot at goal in that period and Hugh Monteith had one of the quietest cup finals of any keeper.
The humiliation complete, the Bury players received the cup and medals from Lord Kinnaird who had won five winners medals in the 1870's and 80's.
Derby would be back, although they would have to wait over forty years for their next final and to at last get their hands on the cup. Bury were not so lucky and marked the centenary of their last cup final appearance in 2003 with a walk to their third division fixture at Rochdale to raise money to try and save the club from extinction.
TEAMS
BURY
HUGH MONTEITH
J LINDASY
JIMMY MCEWEN
W JOHNSTONE
F THORPE
GEORGE ROSS {CAPTAIN}
W RICHARDS
WILLIAM WOOD
CHARLIE SAGAR
JOE LEEMING
JOHN PLANT
DERBY COUNTY
JACK FRYER
JIMMY METHVEN
CHARLIE MORRIS
BEN WARREN
ARCHIE GOODALL {CAPTAIN}
JOHN MAY
JOE WARRINGTON
CHARLIE YORK
JOHN BOAG
GEORGE RICHARDS
GEORGE DAVIS